Competing visions: Expanding cultural arts and parks vs. building a new convention center

Author Avatar
The Austin Convention Center under demolition.
The Austin Convention Center under demolition. Image credit: Andrew Wheat.
Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

​​Almost a year after the Austin City Council voted to demolish the downtown convention center and sink $1.6 billion into a larger replacement, the future of that new downtown convention center might be left up to voters.

Kirk Watson
Kirk Watson

Austin Mayor Kirk Watson argues that it is a done deal, making the case for a state-of-the-art convention center that won’t cost local taxpayers a dime since it’s being built with hotel occupancy taxes (HOT) that are mostly paid by visitors.

But not all residents share that vision, noting that Austin has neglected a primary economic generator: The city’s cultural arts – including music, performance art, film, historic sites, parks, and other attractions – that benefit residents and visitors from across the globe.

The latter group has organized a “Save the Soul of Austin” campaign backed by the Austin United PAC. They are circulating a petition to ask voters in May 2026 to postpone convention center reconstruction “until approved by voters, or for seven years.” The proposed measure also would prioritize “city financial support for Austin local live music, arts, cultural and outdoor tourism.” The group faces a mid-October deadline to gather 20,000 valid signatures. If they succeed, the matter goes to voters for an up or down vote next year.

These dueling visions of how the city should use its hotel tax revenue – for the new convention center or cultural arts and parks – were captured in recent Austin American-Statesman opinion pieces.

Watson argued that Austin lags behind the convention-industry curve and should invest in a bigger facility to generate billions of tourism-related dollars.

“We’re the country’s 13th largest city, and a top visitors’ destination, but our convention center ranks No. 61 in size,” he wrote. “Our staff routinely turn down major events because we don’t have the space. Those marquee events go to other cities that reap the economic benefit.”

David Heymann
David Heymann

In laying out an alternate vision for building a “cultural arts district” on the same downtown blocks, University of Texas architecture professor David Heymann also argued that Austin is falling behind by not investing in an “art museum, performing arts center, experimental theater, media-arts center and other amenities” as Dallas, Houston, Fort Worth and San Antonio have done. Those cities “have great cultural arts districts that enrich cultural life, give educational value, provide civic identity, serve residents and visitors and bring in money,” Heymann wrote.

Dueling impacts

A huge pile of tax dollars is at stake. The new convention center’s $1.6 billion construction budget does not include an estimated $80 million a year in operating costs and up to $26 million per year to fund the city’s promotional office, Visit Austin.

HVS consulting firm estimates that over 30 years the new facility will cost $5.6 billion and generate $1.6 billion in direct revenue. That would require $4 billion in public subsidies that would consume 80 percent of Austin’s hotel tax revenues over the next three decades.

University of Texas at San Antonio professor emeritus Heywood Sanders, who has studied convention centers nationwide, cautions that consultants often are wildly optimistic in forecasting new convention center business.

UT San Antonio Professor Heywood Sanders stars in a new film about the Austin Convention Center.
UT San Antonio Professor Heywood Sanders stars in a new film about the Austin Convention Center.
Image credit: Steve Mims.

In an Austin Free Press documentary released earlier this year, “The Magic Hole,” Sanders said, “A reasonable rule-of-thumb conclusion is that you’ll get about half of what the consultant forecasts.” When Austin expanded the convention center in 2000, its consultant overestimated its business by about that margin.

The above estimates exclude indirect economic multiplier effects that occur as conventioneers also spend money in local stores and restaurants. The expanded convention center “will have a projected $750 million annual economic impact on Austin and will generate an additional $13 million a year in direct city tax revenue paid by visitors,” Watson wrote in his American-Statesman commentary. “Over the next 20 years, the expansion will inject an estimated $15 billion into the city’s economy.”

Sanders argues that this money “benefits a small handful of people who have erected a system and structure that very neatly benefits them.”

Austin collected $133.3 million in hotel tax revenues in 2024, according to Texas Comptroller data. The city spent $79.6 million of that on the convention center (59.7 percent), $22.7 million on advertising (17 percent), while arts and historic preservation each got $15. 6 million apiece (11.7 percent each).

Texas tax law mandates that hotel taxes be spent to promote “tourism and the convention and hotel industry.” City officials interpret that narrowly. Currently, the city funds only five of the law’s nine statutory categories: convention center, convention center administration, advertising, arts, and heritage. Other authorized categories include sporting venues, sports venue upgrades, and tourist transit and signage.

Governor Greg Abbott
Greg Abbott

In a 2003 advisory opinion, then-Texas Attorney General Greg Abbott concluded that local governments have wide latitude to spend that tax money so long as they determine that it promotes “tourism and the convention and the hotel industry.”

According to that opinion, the city council can spend hotel-tax revenues on parks if it determines that doing so promotes tourism, hotels, and the convention center. Indeed, Cameron County in South Texas passed a special state legislative provision authorizing it to spend hotel taxes on the South Texas EcoTourism Center.

Second thoughts, more equity

Latching onto this idea, critics argue that investing in local parks, historical preservation and arts represent smarter tourism investments of hotel tax dollars that play on Austin’s strengths.

UT’s Heymann wrote in his piece, that, “Though demolition has begun, the site’s future is not decided.”

Demolition site with photo of its successor.
Demolition site with photo of its successor.
Image credit: Andrew Wheat.

“We’re still in the field,” said Austin United PAC organizer Bill Bunch, eyeing a mid-October deadline to collect enough valid signatures to ask voters to halt reconstruction. “We should finish up in the next two or three weeks.”

Bill Bunch

Bunch said that volunteers have collected more than the required 20,000 signatures but a “lot of them are invalid” because the signers live outside city limits. “We’re validating as we go. We want to make sure we have a safety margin because we know the city will mess with us if they can.”

Noting that there has been extensive community engagement on a new convention center for more than a decade, Watson wrote that the project is backed by local arts and heritage organizations, as well as the national convention industry.

“Yeah, we voted,” he wrote, referring to a failed ballot initiative to derail the project in 2019. “This question has been asked and answered, over and over. It’s time to move forward.”

Watson’s commentary does not mention that Travis County voters overwhelmingly passed a 2019 proposition to raise hotel taxes 2 percent to renovate East Austin’s aging Exposition Center. Then-Travis County Judge Sarah Eckhardt warned at the time that the county might need to abandon the ailing Expo Center without more funding. Home to Rodeo Austin, that facility spurs $77 million of economic impact in just 15 days each year. Yet the city of Austin claimed those tax dollars for the convention center, creating a local-government rift.

Precinct 1 Travis County Commissioner Jeff Travillion.
Jeff Travillion

Back then, Travis County Commissioner Jeff Travillion denounced the inequity of spending more than $1 billion in tax dollars in a downtown area with fewer than 20,000 residents instead of an eastside venue that serves “more than half a million people.

Two convention centers

The competing Statesman op-eds came out on the same day that Austin Convention Center officials announced the start of preliminary construction on the new facility’s foundation — and as the city involves itself in a second convention center to be built near the Circuit of the Americas racetrack.

“While demolition of the existing facility continues, crews have now begun diaphragm wall (D-wall) activities, the critical first step of true structural construction,” said a Sept. 3. press release on the downtown convention center.

Circuit of the Americas Formula 1 racetrack.
Circuit of the Americas Formula 1 racetrack.
Image credit: Circuit of the Americas.

Meanwhile, the city recently inked a deal with Houston-based RIDA Development Corp. to build a privately-funded 460,000-square -foot convention center and 1,000-bed hotel. That complex is to be built on 21 acres that the city bought near the Circuit of Americas track in July. This allows the city to collect hotel occupancy taxes there.

Tom Noonan
Tom Noonan

The proposed racetrack convention center is larger than the 370,000-square-foot one being demolished downtown. “Because of the new Austin Convention Center’s size, as well as central downtown location, we don’t anticipate there being much competition between the two different spaces,” Visit Austin CEO Tom Noonan told Community Impact.

UT’s Heymann argues that the racetrack convention center supports his argument for converting six downtown blocks into a cultural mecca.

“Historically, most cities across the United States — understand cultural infrastructure is necessary and take pride in providing it,” he wrote. “Many Austinites hope we can stay a town, a weird one. But it’s creepy weird, not cute, weird, how far behind we are (in) supporting culture broadly and deeply.”

“The argument that a new convention center would hurt funding for the arts is silly,” Watson’s commentary countered. “More than $40 million a year in local hotel tax funding is earmarked for arts and heritage funding. Using the hotel tax as it’s intended does not ‘take away’ from funding other Austin needs or desires.”

Richard Stone is a Central Texas native reporter and editor with 35 years of award-winning experience covering local issues that matter. More at Wilcoblues.com.

Disclosure: Bill Bunch sits on the Austin Free Press advisory board.

Support independent journalism. Your tax-deductible donation helps keep independent journalism free. 

Read More

Scroll to Top