Austin’s smart growth damages people of color

Author Avatar
Huston-Tillotson University Austin Free Press independent journalism partnership
This story is part of Huston-Tillotson University’s journalism-training partnership with the Austin Free Press.
Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

There has been significant growth in urban development over the past few decades in Austin, Texas, leading to economic prosperity for some while displacing others. The Austin City Council passed two initiatives in April 2000 to sustainably manage growth: the Desired Development Zone and the S.M.A.R.T. Housing program. While these programs concentrated development in specific areas and provided some affordable housing they contributed to the displacement of low-income and minority communities.

The City of Austin’s Desired Development Zone was part of the city’s Smart Growth Initiative. It sought to keep redevelopment away from West Austin’s environmentally sensitive Edwards Aquifer and Barton Springs recharge zones to protect Barton Springs and its endangered salamanders. Instead, the Desired Development Zone targeted areas that “extended north from downtown and the University of Texas campus to the north and east of I-35” Barna explains in “The Rise and Fall of Smart Growth in Austin.”

However, concentrating development in the Desired Development Zone led to unintended consequences. In a 2019 article in Harvard Urban Review, Ethan Levin explains that as investments poured into these designated areas, property values escalated, making housing less affordable for long-term residents. This development surge often overlooked the needs of low-income and minority populations, who found themselves priced out of their neighborhoods. While the Desired Development Zone delivered some economic growth and environmental benefits, it did not adequately address the social implications of this rapid urbanization.

In response to the growing need for affordable housing, Austin introduced the S.M.A.R.T. housing program. This program aimed to provide safe, mixed-income, accessible, reasonably priced, and transit-oriented housing. It offered developers incentives such as fee waivers and expedited permit processes in exchange for including affordable units in their projects. The program faced implementation challenges. It did not build enough affordable units and the units that were built were too expensive for those most in need. Additionally, these new developments led to the displacement of existing residents as revitalization efforts increased property values and living costs.

The combined effects of the Desired Development Zone and the S.M.A.R.T. Housing initiatives have accelerated gentrification in several Austin neighborhoods. Studies show that as new developments emerge, longstanding communities, particularly those of African American and Latinx residents face increased rents and property taxes, forcing many to relocate further from the city’s center.

In a response to its history of displacing Black and Brown communities, the City of Austin recently introduced Project Connect, a comprehensive transit expansion plan that allocated $300 million specifically for anti-displacement efforts and a displacement risk map and dashboard. These measures have yet to successfully mitigate displacement in Austin, however.

Austin’s S.M.A.R.T. Housing and the Desired Development Zone initiatives highlight the need for systemic change and intentional care for all Austin populations as the city continues expanding. These programs sought to provide support for affordable housing and sustainable development, but instead, they also accelerated gentrification and displacement. The City of Austin needs greater dedication to establishing an inclusive urban environment that strikes a balance between expansion and the needs of all Austin residents.

Scroll to Top