| Getting your Trinity Audio player ready... |
Early voting begins today for Austin’s Nov. 3 election, including Proposition I — a City Charter amendment proposal to require an independent audit of city spending every five years. It has opponents and supporters clashing over the need for further oversight of city spending.

“The goal of Prop I is to create a new base of information and ideas to make the city more affordable, the council more accountable, and increase voter trust,” said a statement from attorney Bill Aleshire, the former Travis County judge who helped draft the proposition.
Opponents say that Austin already has an independent City Auditor and recently approved an outside efficiency assessment, making the charter amendment itself an unnecessary expense.

The measure is “just another giveaway to corporate consultants,” said District 2 Council Member Vanessa Fuentes at a City Hall rally against the proposal earlier this month. “They know that this service will be locked in via the city charter, so that the city will have no choice but to hire them, and then they get to set the price.”
Fuentes said that the measure creates a “conflict of interest” by requiring the consultants to find enough potential savings to pay their own fees. “They can make proposals that are not feasible, that don’t work, and that are not aligned with our Austin values, “ she said at the event organized by the Austinites for Equity Political Action Committee.
Aleshire aligns Proposition I with Austin voters’ rejection of last year’s proposed Proposition Q property-tax increase. He told Austin Free Press that the new measure would inform the Austin City Council and the public about future budget and tax decisions, providing “better ideas about how to improve the Austin City government.”
Proposition I will see what residents get from city spending and which programs produce results, Aleshire said. It requires the outside auditor to identify savings to ensure that the audits pay for themselves, as Houston did, Aleshire said. “In Houston, the fee was $500,000, and they found $128 million in potential savings.”
Speakers at the opposition rally featuring representatives of local labor and progressive organizations cast the audit measure as part of a broader political fight over government spending on public services.
U.S. Rep. Greg Casar, (D-Austin) compared Proposition I to the Elon Musk-led federal Department of Government Efficiency, or DOGE. He told the crowd that DOGE cut government services and workers, including the accidental firing of nuclear safety workers. “Prop I would be Austin’s own version of Elon Musk’s DOGE,” he said.

“Nobody here wants waste, fraud, or abuse,” said the former member of Austin’s city council. Brydan Summers, president of American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees (AFSCME) Local 1624 agreed that Proposition I could endanger city services and employees.
“It will lead to perhaps tens of millions of dollars in cuts to programs that Austinites use every day,” he told Austin Free Press. “Core services Austinites rely on in their everyday lives could be cut, which will lead to pain felt across our city.”
AFSCME is the top contributor to the Austinites for Equity PAC that’s leading Proposition I opposition. The union provided almost half of the $101,348 that the PAC raised this year, according to city records.

Austin Central Labor Council President Joe Cooper told Austin Free Press that the city’s existing efficiency assessment was developed with labor involvement and “makes sure the audits are focused on efficiency, not just slashing budgets.”
“This is how audits are supposed to work, finding ways to perform better,” Cooper said. “It shouldn’t be about starting with the assumption that we need to cut $10 million from the budget every audit cycle.”
Supporters reject the idea that the measure would hand excess power to outside consultants.

Matt Mackowiak co-founded the nonprofit Save Austin Now that collected signatures to put Proposition I on the ballot. He cited the measure’s broad support, noting that 21,100 Austinites signed the Save Austin Now petition.
“We are going to pass it,” Mackowiak said, “and the people who oppose it the loudest are the ones who are the most afraid of transparency, accountability, and efficiency.”
Save Austin Now PAC raised nine times as much money as opponent Austinites for Equity PAC so far this year and spent four times as much. Footing the bill to put Proposition I on the ballot, Save Austin’s Now’s top recent donor was the Susan Jeannette Ogden Property Trust ($11,500), tied to the daughter of the original founders of El Arroyo Restaurant.
“How is it that an audit is good if the Council requires it, but bad if the public requires it?” asked a statement from proposition supporter group New Day Austin. “In a democracy, citizens create their government. They can vote directly on laws and policies, such as Prop I.”
The PACs leading the charge for and against Proposition I paid substantial consulting fees to their PAC leaders. Save Austin Now reported spending about $187,000 since July 1. It paid $44,305 to the consulting firm of Save Austin Now co-founder Matt Mackowiak: the Potomac Strategy Group.
During that period, Austinites for Equity spent $23,453 with all of it going to Hernandez Wick Campaigns. It’s headed by PAC spokesperson Laura Hernandez. Hernandez led successful efforts to defeat a 2021 Save Austin Now proposition that would have required the city to hire at least two police officers for every 1,000 city residents.

Source: City of Austin
Austin Free Press Data, Information and Enterprise Editor Andrew Wheat contributed to this report.
