| Getting your Trinity Audio player ready... |
Linda Curtis was struck by déjà vu last month when the Austin city clerk invalidated a citizen petition drive challenging the city’s plan to build a $1.6 billion convention center.
Nearly 30 years ago, Curtis helped run the 1996 “Austinites for a Little Less Corruption” petition drive to adopt city campaign finance limits. Then, like now, a city clerk invalidated the petition. Subsequently, a federal judge, in a sharply worded ruling, reversed the city, saying it had unfairly disqualified signatures for a variety of reasons. That cleared the way for the campaign finance limits measure to be put on the ballot. Austin voters approved it by 70 percent in 1997.
Over the past 30 years, city officials have sometimes rejected citizen petitions that courts later validated and put on a ballot. In the 1990s campaign finance case, a judge cited the city for wrongly invalidating signatures for such things as voters not including “Street” or apartment numbers in their addresses.
Fast forward to Nov. 14. Curtis and others told Austin Free Press that the reasons cited for invalidating convention center signatures are as suspicious now as they were in 1996.

“When the powers that be don’t like what you’re doing, obstruction is their tactic,” said Craig McDonald, who helped organize the 1990s campaign finance reforms as head of Austin nonprofit Texans for Public Justice. “That’s what they did on $100 limits and it looks like that’s what they’re doing on the convention center.”
Curtis agreed that the clerk’s invalidation of signatures “was as ridiculous then as it is now.”

In all, Austin City Clerk Erika Brady invalidated 23% of the 25,441 signatures Austin United PAC submitted in October. That conclusion was based on a sampling of 25% of the total.
Brady’s “Certificate of Insufficiency” said that the stricken signatures were duplicates, missing a signature, not on voter rolls, or rejected “for other reasons.” After those invalidations, the petition fell 494 signatures short of the legal threshold to put the measure on the May ballot, Brady said.
“Based on an independent, third-party review, the City is highly confident (99.986%) that the number of valid signatures is less than the 20,000 required to place the item on the ballot,” said Brady’s written statement earlier this month.
Disputing those claims, United Austin PAC is scrutinizing the signatures that the city disqualified. Both sides are digging in, setting the stage for another potential legal battle to determine if the measure will appear on the ballot next May.
“We hope to resolve our disagreement amicably,” said an Austin United PAC statement, “but will bring prompt legal action if necessary.”

Petitioning government
At issue are 1,027 signatories that Brady said weren’t on the city’s voter rolls and another 443 that she disqualified for “other reasons.”

Austin United PAC Treasurer Tanya Payne said that the group worked with a software company on signature validation. “We have extensive notes that we’ll be comparing” to the invalidated signatures.
“We’re trying to work with the city clerk to come to a mutual agreement,” Payne said. “At this time, I remain cautiously optimistic.”
Austin Free Press verified that in at least three petition drives going back to 1996, courts ruled that Austin city officials wrongfully blocked citizen initiatives:
- In 1991, the city council refused to put on the ballot a validated Save Our Springs Coalition petition proposing a stringent water-quality ordinance. After SOS prevailed in court, 64% of voters approved that ordinance in 1992.
- In 1996, after a clerk invalidated a petition drive for campaign finance limits, a federal judge ruled that the clerk’s “draconian, misguided insistence that information on the petition match up letter for letter with information on the voter rolls did not fairly or reasonably distinguish between unqualified and qualified voters.”
- In 2018, the city clerk validated signatures seeking to challenge the city’s pending CodeNext land-use rules. But the city council refused to put it on the ballot. After a judge ordered it on the ballot, 52% of Austin voters defeated the proposition to require voters to approve city land-use revisions.
Moody voters
Earlier this month, voters overwhelmingly rejected a yearly $110 million permanent tax rate increase proposed by the city council.
A poll conducted from Oct. 5 to 9 found an electorate unreceptive to spending $5 billion in hotel tax dollars over the lifetime of the proposed new convention center. Just 9% percent of respondents said that they supported that expenditure, with 76% opposed. Environmental activist Robin Rather commissioned the landline and text poll of 585 registered Austin voters from Public Policy Polling. The poll has a margin of error of plus or minus 4 percentage points with a 95% confidence level.

Mayor Kirk Watson acknowledged voters’ concerns over city spending and public distrust of the city’s fiscal management. In the Nov. 21 edition of his Watson Wire newsletter, the mayor countered those who want the city to spend hotel tax dollars on priorities other than the convention center. Hotel taxes “can’t be spent on general government services,” Watson wrote.
Meanwhile, the city council is forging ahead with convention center construction preparations. Ten days after Austin United filed its petition with the city clerk, the city council voted on Oct. 23 to increase convention center contracts by $990 million and to issue almost $700 million in convention center-related bonds.
Petition organizer Linda Curtis said that the council is fast tracking convention center initiatives and spending to make it harder to derail by the time the petition can appear on a ballot.

Former City Council Member Max Nofziger agreed, recalling the 1996 campaign finance limits petition drive. He told Austin Free Press that when he unsuccessfully ran against Watson for mayor in 1997 his campaign would have benefitted if the city had put the campaign finance reform measure on the mayoral ballot. Instead, a judge ordered it on the ballot months after Watson won the mayoral election.
Holding both elections on the same day “would have favored me, I have no doubt,” Nofziger said. He backed the campaign finance limits, which Watson did not. Today, Nofziger sees the invalidation of the convention center petition as another delay tactic by city officials.
“Given what happened with (the tax increase proposal) Proposition Q, I think the chances are that the citizens are in a mood to shoot down an enormously expensive convention center project,” he said. “So, I can see why the city council would charge ahead and try to do everything they could prior to a May election to make sure the convention center is a fait accompli.”

Andrew Wheat is the managing editor of the Austin Free Press.

