False equivalency: The Affordable-housing fees that downtown developers pay Austin come up short

Author Avatar
Developer fees-in-lieu incentives helped transform downtown Austin’s skyline.
Developer fees-in-lieu incentives helped transform downtown Austin’s skyline. Image credit: MJ Tangonan.
Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

“Current fee-in-lieu policies lead to the displacement of working-class communities of color. Instead, we need to increase the fee and ensure the money is given to community organizations to create and preserve affordable housing in neighborhoods.”
– Organizer Alexia Leclercq

This is the first of a two-part series examining controversial affordable-housing fees that developers in the city’s density-bonus entitlement programs pay instead of building affordable units themselves. Part two analyzes the city’s popular Downtown Density Bonus fee-in-lieu program in greater detail.

The Downtown Density Bonus program — a key tool leveraged by the City of Austin to boost affordable housing supplies — has produced very few units for low and middle-income residents when developers have opted to pay fees-in-lieu rather than building affordable housing themselves. That’s according to an Austin Free Press examination that analyzed the city’s most popular fee-in-lieu program: The Downtown Density Bonus program.

The city now operates 13 density-bonus building entitlement programs that, in exchange for providing some affordable units, allow developers to build more housing on a lot than they otherwise could. Nine of the city’s 13 density-bonus programs also offer a controversial workaround that lets developers pay the city an affordable-housing fee — known as a fee-in-lieu — instead of building income-restricted housing on-site.

At their best, fees-in-lieu benefit both developers and the public. Developers can build more market-rate apartments in high-income areas, such as downtown Austin, and therefore bypass building income-restricted units on-site. In exchange, the city can use the developer fees to build affordable housing in less affluent areas. City officials supporting the fees note that it costs less to build income-restricted apartments in less-affluent areas, so they say the city can get more affordable units when developers pay fees-in-lieu.

Fees-in-lieu remain controversial, however, with opponents saying that they contribute to Austin’s economic and racial segregation. The Free Press analysis further finds that fewer affordable units get built when the city collects fees-in-lieu. Moreover, the city has been slow to inflation-adjust the fees that participating developers pay, undermining buying power for affordable housing.

Under Texas law, cities cannot require developers to build affordable housing through inclusionary zoning. As a result, Austin officials say that they must rely on density-bonus incentives to help solve Austin’s housing shortage.

“The Density Bonus tool is one of the primary tools the City of Austin has to generate much needed affordable housing,” said a city-commissioned report that the City Council received in January.

In establishing the Downtown Density Bonus Program in 2013, for example, the Austin City Council said that it sought to strike a balance that allowed “developers and the community to equitably share the benefits of additional height and density above existing regulations.” The downtown program has become the city’s most popular fee-in-lieu program.

When developers in the Downtown Density Bonus Program pay the fees instead of building affordable units onsite, however, fewer income-restricted units wind up getting built elsewhere, according to an Austin Free Press analysis (see methodology here). The analysis assumes that the Downtown Density Bonus Program would have attracted the same number of projects if fees-in-lieu were not an option. Those finding show that since 2014:

  1. The equivalent of 47 affordable 500-square-foot studio apartments were built with fee-in-lieu dollars; and
  2. Without the fees-in-lieu option, those same developers would have had to build roughly 244 affordable studio apartments onsite — or 197 additional affordable units.

According to a 2023 progress report, the city is on track for reaching its own new housing goals when it comes to units priced between 60 to 80 percent of median family income. For people making less, that goal now seems out of reach.

Source: Housing Works Austin

Against that backdrop, the city is considering expanding the fee-in-lieu option across all of its density-bonus programs. This was a top recommendation of the recent city-commissioned report, which said that the most successful density-bonus programs “provide flexibility in their requirements by offering a fee-in-lieu option,” which “is correlated with greater program participation.” A comprehensive update of the various density-bonus incentives is scheduled to start with the University Neighborhood Overlay program in June.

Fees-in-lieu have been controversial since the city introduced its first density-bonus program in 2004. Supporters say that these fees offer more bang for the buck. They can collect funds from luxury housing downtown, for example, to build more housing in areas with cheaper land.

Greg Anderson
Greg Anderson

“Fee-in-lieu funds are spent on housing needs citywide and can often generate more resources to build additional homes than if affordable units were included in high-cost construction projects,” Austin Planning Commission member Greg Anderson wrote in an email. Anderson also is the community affairs director at Austin Habitat for Humanity, a nonprofit that builds low-income housing.

Austin Developer Ed Wendler with the firm Cypress Real Estate Advisors agrees.

“It’s just hard for me to believe (that) sheltering someone in a high-rise in the name of economic integration makes much sense when we could shelter at least 3 in a different building that is still great space and probably not that far from the high-rise,” Wendler wrote in an email. “I’m not sure it makes sense to shelter 2 families in Tarrytown when 8 could be sheltered on Burnet Road.”

Segregationist fees?

Critics counter that the fee-in-lieu option exacerbates Austin’s racial, ethnic and class segregation — excluding lower-income residents from pricey parts of town. While the fee option should be an exception designated for special circumstances, they say, it instead has morphed into a rule.

Note: 10,364 of Austin’s 979,700 residents lived in its four downtown census tracts (11.01, 11.02, 11.03 and 7) according to the 2020 U.S. Census.
Source: U.S. Census Bureau.
Elizabeth Mueller
Elizabeth Mueller

This more-bang-for-the-buck “logic is what brought us the pattern that we have now,” said Liz Mueller, a professor at UT Austin’s School of Architecture. “We should be building opportunities for people of all different income levels to be there. So (downtown) is not an artificially affluent area that is not accessible to other people.”

Alexia Leclercq
Alexia Leclercq

Alexia Leclercq, an organizer with Community Powered ATX, added: “Current fee-in-lieu policies lead to the displacement of working-class communities of color. Instead, we need to increase the fee and ensure the money is given to community organizations to create and preserve affordable housing in neighborhoods.”

Transformed into a residential neighborhood in recent decades, downtown is today much less racially and economically diverse than is the entire city. In 2023, non-Hispanic whites accounted for 76 percent of residents in downtown census tracts – compared to 54 percent of the city as a whole, according to U.S. Census data.

Kathie Tovo
Kathie Tovo

Fees-in-lieu have “stood in the way of getting affordable housing in parts of town where we really needed it,” said Kathie Tovo, who served on the Austin City Council for more than a decade. “We should try to get those units on-site whenever we can.”

Tovo proposed a resolution back in 2015 directing the city manager to assess the effectiveness of density-bonus programs and to consider eliminating fees-in-lieu altogether. The council approved a pared back version, directing city staff to study the idea.

“The fees-in-lieu that have been collected very rarely are substantial enough to build housing elsewhere,” Tovo said.

Sara Willa Ernst is a freelance writer based in Austin. Before that, she was the health reporter at the NPR station in Houston. Her radio stories have aired on shows like NPR’s All Things Considered, Weekend Edition, The Texas Standard and WHYY’s The Pulse. She has reported and produced two podcasts “Hot Stops” and “Below the Waterlines.” The latter won her two regional Murrow awards in 2023.

Support independent journalism. Your tax-deductible donation helps keep independent journalism free. 

Read More

Scroll to Top