Hot mix: Critics say Austin’s plans to build housing in industrial areas is toxic

Author Avatar
More housing is slated for industrial areas such as this, near Highway 183 and Bolm Road.
More housing is slated for industrial areas such as this, near Highway 183 and Bolm Road. Image credit: Sinclair Temple.
Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

The Austin City Council is considering a new density bonus program this month that would allow developers to construct apartment buildings up to 240 feet high — or 20 stories tall – in industrial-zoned areas in exchange for community benefits.

Housing advocates welcome the zoning change, saying it will generate more affording housing to help meet demand. But the DB240 program is raising alarms among researchers concerned about the serious health risks of building apartments next to some of the city’s worst industrial air polluters and highways.

UT housing professor Elizabeth Mueller was “flabbergasted” by city plans to build housing in toxic industrial areas.
UT housing professor Elizabeth Mueller was “flabbergasted” by city plans to build housing in toxic industrial areas. Image credit: Elizabeth Mueller.

“I was just kind of flabbergasted” when I heard about it, University of Texas researcher Elizabeth Mueller told Austin Free Press. “I feel like sometimes we’re forgetting that housing is for living in.”

“Why would we want to add housing in a place that’s going to put people in harm’s way? Yes, we need to add housing because we’re a growing region, but we should be thinking about where are the right places to add it.”

Austin City Council members are scheduled to take up the DB240 policy on Nov. 21.

The program would incentivize developers to build housing up to a maximum of 240 feet in areas where housing is generally excluded. In exchange, owners would have to provide such community benefits as affordable housing, trees, or pedestrian and cycling infrastructure. The program is similar to the controversial DB90 rezoning tool that the council approved earlier this year, which lets developers build seven-story residences next to single-family homes.

The Austin Planning Commission narrowly endorsed the DB240 plan last month, with some commissioners saying it’s needed to address Austin’s housing crisis.  Planning Commissioner Felicity Maxwell noted the city already approves housing projects in industrial zones but does so without incentivizing affordable housing.

“We need some sort of affordable housing program for (these) sites,” she said at the Planning Commission’s October 22 meeting. “So I will definitely be supporting this.”

Toxic housing concerns

Two University of Texas professors sent letters to the Planning Commission and City Council over the past month, warning that much of the land eligible for DB240 is located within a one mile radius of Austin’s 14 worst air polluters or along major highways. Building housing near those sites could further Austin’s racial health disparities, they said. East Austin’s higher rates of air pollution have been shown to send Black and Latino residents to the hospital for asthma attacks much more often, for example. Most industrial areas eligible for DB240 are east of Interstate 35.

Austin’s top air polluters include landfills, chip manufacturers, energy plants, concrete facilities, and fuel terminals. They emit the most airborne particulate matter (PM2.5), Sulfur Dioxide, or Volatile Organic Compounds, according to Texas Commission on Environmental Quality data. These toxic compounds can irritate the eyes, skin, throat and lungs. Long-term exposure is linked to heart disease, asthma, lung cancer, central nervous system damage, low-birth-weight babies and more.

DB240 Map
Image credit: Elizabeth Mueller & Megan Kannenberg.

“I would strongly encourage you to reconsider this,” wrote Mueller, a professor who researches housing-policy at the University of Texas. “The DB240 proposal before you actually adds residential use to an area currently zoned for… uses that spew pollutants known to endanger people living nearby.”

A letter that UT School of Architecture professor Alex Karner wrote officials focused on how DB240 would allow housing to be built right next to highways. Karner wrote that vehicle exhaust is a major contributor to respiratory diseases. Studies have found elevated pollutant levels within 0.3 miles of a busy highway or road.

“The research on that is really clear,” echoed Elizabeth Mueller. “It’s not a good idea to have people live right next to a highway that you know has a lot of traffic.” Mueller urged the council to not allow housing “within 1,000 feet of a major highway.”

Homes everywhere?

DB240 is part of a recent council push to build more housing. Explosive growth, accompanied by declining housing affordability and the displacement of long-time residents has prompted local politicians to promote a pro-building agenda.

In July, Austin City Council directed the Planning and Zoning Department to draft DB240 to fine tune the Planning Development Area (PDA) rezoning tool that developers currently use to build housing in industrial areas. The PDA program has been used to rezone 45 industrial properties for residential uses since 2014, according to Austin Planning Department data. The city approved almost 70% of those projects just within the past 4 years.

The Austin City Council conceived DB240 as a way to extract community benefits from residential developers of industrial sites — something that the existing Planning Development Area tool lacks. DB240 “is trying to address that (council’s) request to require community benefits when we’re giving these sites additional entitlements,” Alan Pani, the city’s principal planner, said at a public meeting on DB240 on October 28.

“Not ideal places”

The Planning Department does not evaluate air quality when it reviews rezoning requests, city planning officials said at the October 28 meeting. However, staff does consider land uses on the site in question, as well as adjacent properties. “We definitely understand that highways are not ideal places for residential developments and I know our zoning team does review for appropriate locations,” Pani said. “Heavy industrial uses” are not “compatible” with residential.

However, proximity to busy highways and polluting industrial facilities has not always stopped these kinds of projects.

The city approved new housing for this industrial area near Highway 183 and Bolm Road.
The city approved new housing for this industrial area near Highway 183 and Bolm Road. Image credit: Google Maps.

A PDA case that the Council approved in April is redeveloping land off Highway 183 in East Austin into more than 2,200 units of multi-family housing, retail and office space. That parcel also is home to one of Austin’s 12 top air polluters, an asphalt and concrete plant called Hot Mix, according to Elizabeth Mueller at UT. “The recent rezoning and addition of residential use to the Austin Hot Mix site appears not to have considered adjacent industrial uses incompatible,” she wrote to the council.

Hot Mix did not immediately return a call about whether it would relocate; its industrial neighbors SouthWaste Disposal and Wastewater Transport Services are likely to stay.

UT Professor Elizabeth Mueller said the DB240 ordinance should include “a list of uses considered incompatible with residential uses either on a rezoned site or adjacent to it.” “This should not be left up to interpretation. Staff — and applicants— need to have a clear decision rule.”

“Historically it hasn’t been staff that prevents rezoning, it’s community opposition,” Mueller said. “There need to be really clear standards.”

Bearing the brunt

Some community organizers and civil rights groups oppose DB240. Nelson Linder, president of the NAACP’s Austin chapter, said city officials should engage groups like his early in the process and actively seek feedback while drafting such ordinances.

“We know what’s in these areas,” said Linder. “Why would you do that based on the risk involved? These ideas show a lack of respect, a lack of conversations with folks who do care. You’re not talking to the right people in advance.”

Community leaders Nelson Linder (left) and Alexia Leclerc (right) object to putting housing in industrial areas.
Community leaders Nelson Linder (left) and Alexia Leclercq (right) object to putting housing in industrial areas. Image credit: Nelson Linder & Alexia Leclercq.

Alexia Leclercq, Policy Director at PODER, an environmental justice non-profit in East Austin, said that the affordable housing required doesn’t serve her community. A developer taking advantage of the full 120 feet of extra building height would need to set aside 12% of all units for renters making below $44,100 annually — or 15% of the units for renters making below $52,920. Leclercq says truly affordable housing must be accessible to people making $25,000 to $40,000 a year.

Areas eligible to build housing near industrial areas under DB204 are concentrated on one side of town, evoking some dark history. The city’s segregated 1928 Master Plan pushed Austin’s Blacks — along with its industrial pollution — into East Austin. Hispanics also were displaced there.

“Building affordable housing next to the highway or other polluting industry is something we would push back on,” Leclercq said. “Black and Brown residents from East Austin have already borne the brunt of pollution in Austin for decades and suffered the health consequences. We want deeply affordable housing and green spaces for Black and Brown people.”

Support independent journalism. Your tax-deductible donation helps keep independent journalism free. 

Read More

Scroll to Top