In Focus: UT professor reopens “The Eyes of Texas” controversy

Author Avatar
University of Texas students sing “The Eyes of Texas” during a Longhorn football game. The song's century old tradition is at the center of ongoing debate.
University of Texas students sing “The Eyes of Texas” during a Longhorn football game. The song's century old tradition is at the center of ongoing debate. Credit: Corpx/Wikimedia Commons
Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

A University of Texas at Austin professor is challenging the university’s official history of “The Eyes of Texas,” arguing that it emerged from racist traditions that earlier research downplayed.

 

Alberto Martinez
Alberto Martinez

Alberto Martinez, speaking at the Carver Branch of the Austin Public Library earlier this month, unveiled findings from his new book, “The Eyes of Texas: From Blackface to Whitewash.” His research disputes the 2021 Eyes of Texas History Committee report, which concluded the song was not written with “overtly” racist intent.

Caption: The cover of “The Eyes of Texas: From Blackface to Whitewash” by UT professor Alberto Martinez
Caption: The cover of “The Eyes of Texas: From Blackface to Whitewash” by UT professor Alberto Martinez
Credit: Saltshadow Castle
Jay Hartzell
Jay Hartzell

The song exploded into national news during 2020 Black Lives Matter protests after George Floyd’s murder, pushing UT to create the history committee. In March 2021, then-UT President Jay Hartzell announced that the university would maintain the “Eyes of Texas” as the university’s official song after reviewing the history committee’s report.

Hartzell said in 2025 that it was one of the most difficult issues of his presidency, as it created a hostile environment in pitting donors and alumni against students.

Martinez’s research disputes much of the university’s findings, arguing that the song’s historical context reveals deeper roots in racism, including influence from a Confederate general, a melody borrowed from a song about Black convict labor, and its debut at the first campus minstrel show.

University of Texas at Austin officials did not respond to requests for comment and members of the Eyes of Texas History Committee were unavailable for interviews.

In March 2021 when the 58-page report was released, it stated in its executive summary: “These historical facts add complexity and richness to the story of a song that debuted in a racist setting, exceedingly common for the time, but, as the preponderance of research showed, had no racist intent.”

“The Eyes of Texas'” should not only unite us, but hold all of us accountable to our institution’s core values.”

Chain gang of convict workers waiting for food, near Asheville, NC, 1915.
Chain gang of convict workers waiting for food, near Asheville, NC, 1915.
Credit: North Carolina Office of Archives and History, Raleigh; call no. N_71_9_145

Back to the Civil War

At the Carver Library, Martinez told attendees that the report didn’t fully acknowledge the role of blackface performance and “whitewashed” its origins, leaving the criticism unresolved, and that the persistence of the song reflects how strongly institutions hold onto traditions.

“Culture can be more solid than a rock,” he said.

Part of Martínez’s research focused on tracing the origin of the phrase “the eyes of Texas are upon you.” It is associated with UT president William Prather, who served from 1899 to his death in 1905, and often used the expression in speeches when addressing students. Initially believed to be inspired by Confederate General Robert E. Lee, the history committee found no primary source linking the phrase to him.

Robert E. Lee
Robert E. Lee
Credit: Library of Congress

However, Martinez discovered first-person accounts from Civil War soldiers in the Texas Brigade that describe an anecdote during the Battle of the Wilderness in 1864 when Confederate General John Gregg rallied troops by telling them that, “The eyes of General Lee are upon you.’”

John Gregg
John Gregg
Credit: Wikipedia

He also argued that Prather admired Lee, studying under him while attending Washington and Lee University. In a 1938 memoir, former UT dean Thomas Taylor wrote that Prather told him he had paraphrased Lee, who as president of the college often closed speeches with the phrase “the eyes of the South are upon you.” Martinez noted that Prather was even a pallbearer at Lee’s funeral in 1870.

“He tried to bring some of the values, dignity, and military discipline that General Lee had to UT Austin with great pride,” Martinez said.

Both the history committee and Martinez found that Prather’s adapted catchphrase would become the inspiration for a song debuted at the university’s first minstrel show in 1903, with Prather in attendance.

Minstrel show origins

 John Lang Sinclair
John Lang Sinclair
Credit: University of Texas at Austin

Martinez said the history of the song comes into sharper focus when taking a closer look at its minstrel origins. Historical records he reviewed show that “The Eyes of Texas” was written specifically for the 1903 performance, which was staged at the Hancock Opera House to raise money for the university’s track team. Martinez found that UT student John Lang Sinclair, a member of the glee club, was tasked with writing the song under pressure on the day of the performance, as the group had committed to sing a song titled ‘The Eyes of Texas Are Upon You,” but didn’t have lyrics.

“They take his clothing off down to his underwear, they put him in a closet, they give him tobacco to smoke, and they say, ‘you’re not getting out of that closet until you write a song,’” Martinez said.

The performance itself followed a common format for early 20th-century minstrel shows, which typically featured white performers in blackface portraying exaggerated caricatures of Black Americans through songs, skits, and comedy routines.

“This is the birth of our song,” Martinez said. “It came from bullying and from racism.”

Martinez argued that this context is central to understanding the song’s creation and meaning. Blackface performances, he said, were a key part of popular entertainment during the Jim Crow era and often mocked Black Americans’ efforts to gain equality.

The history committee concluded that the 1903 minstrel show occurred near the end of an era across the nation, as the genre was evolving into vaudeville. Martinez noted that this was just the beginning for UT, as minstrel performances remained part of campus entertainment up to the mid-1960s.

More than a borrowed melody

Martinez’s research also focuses on the music itself, finding that the melody and form of “The Eyes of Texas” was borrowed from “The Levee Song,” which later evolved into the well-known folk tune “I’ve Been Working on the Railroad.” Both versions have minstrel origins.

“I was very fond of that old song…so I decided to write words to that tune,” Sinclair wrote in another account.

While mocking their dialect, the songs reflected the conditions faced by Blacks in the post-Civil War South, particularly those forced into labor through the convict leasing system. After the Civil War ended and slavery was abolished, many Southern states began arresting Black men on minor charges and renting them to private companies as laborers facing harsh and abusive conditions.

The history committee found that Sinclair chose a tune that many students were already familiar with so they could learn the song quickly, and that borrowing melodies was a common practice in the 19th century. Martinez argued that while the song’s goal was to parody, it borrowed more than the melody, with some lyrics and form pulled directly from the original sources. “The (UT) Texas anthem of higher education stems from a song about uneducated black convicts,” Martinez said. “It’s connected to the history of slavery.”

Credit: Shelby Ligon
Credit: Shelby Ligon

Tradition and resistance to change

Over time, “The Eyes of Texas” took on a life of its own, evolving into a lasting tradition. Martínez found that Sinclair later wrote with incredulity about the song’s popularity, as it had been intended for only one performance.

In a letter to a friend, Sinclair wrote, “There can be no reasonable explanation for such an outrage as the original hymn, except that someone thought the minstrel performance undignified and sought to improve it.”

 Leon Holland, circa 1960. Holland was a member of The Precursors, and graduated from UT in 1961.Credit: Texas Exes/The Alcalde
Leon Holland, circa 1960. Holland was a member of The Precursors, and graduated from UT in 1961.
Credit: Texas Exes/The Alcalde

The song’s rise also coincided with a period when Black students were excluded from the university. UT did not begin admitting Black undergraduate students until the 1950s following legal challenges in the Brown v. Board of Education in 1954. The first official cohort of Black students known as The Precursors, began classes in the fall of 1956 and faced hostility and isolation on campus, further complicating the song’s evolution from a minstrel performance into a unifying school tradition. Black students currently make up just 4.6% of the undergraduate student body at UT. By contrast, African Americans make up an estimated 13.7% of the Texas population.

Skyller Walkes
Skyller Walkes

Martinez’s research is more important as history is being banned in public schools, libraries, and higher education institutions, said Skyller Walkes, a former dean of Diversity Equity and Inclusion for UT’s College of Pharmacy. Walkes now serves on Columbia University’s faculty.

“The primary sources Dr. Martinez references in (his book) are so clearly accessible to those interested in actually learning the truth that it makes any counter argument against what he’s laid bare utterly incredulous,” Walkes told Austin Free Press. “And he presents it all without opinion. . .It’s stated without controversy, simply as supported fact.”

Shelby Ligon is the editorial manager for Austin Free Press.

Support independent journalism. Your tax-deductible donation helps keep independent journalism free. 

Read More

Scroll to Top