| Getting your Trinity Audio player ready... |
Twenty-five years ago, then-Gov. Rick Perry signed the Texas Fair Defense Act into law, with the promise of guaranteeing indigent defendants access to legal representation. Today, advocates are sounding an alarm, claiming that an acute shortage of public defense attorneys across Texas is undercutting that promise, making it difficult for those without money to get the justice they deserve.

Scott Ehlers, executive director of the Texas Indigent Defense Commission (TIDC), calls it “a problem that’s going to get worse” as aging public defense attorneys retire. “Right now, we don’t have enough new lawyers taking their place.”

“It is extremely serious,” said state Sen. Sarah Eckhardt (D-Austin), who has advocated for more funding of public defense attorneys. “We don’t have sufficient criminal defense capacity across the state of Texas, and it’s particularly difficult in rural parts of the state.”
Texas has lost more than 1,600 public defense attorneys since 2014, according to the TIDC.

“A fourth of the criminal defense bar is gone” statewide, said Geoff Burkhart, county executive for Community Legal Services for Travis County,
Money problems
A 2023 study by the Sixth Amendment Center in Cambridge, Mass., ranked Texas 46th nationally in per capita spending on indigent defense.

Former Democratic state Sen. Rodney Ellis, who authored the Fair Defense Act, said in a statement to the Austin Free Press that the act hasn’t achieved its goals primarily because of a funding imbalance between counties and the state. Ellis currently serves as a Harris County commissioner.
Texas’ indigent defense costs run around $400 million annually. In fiscal year 2025 the state paid just 8.3% of the costs, according to a TIDC spokesperson, leaving the bulk of the burden to counties.
Burkhart, a former head of the Texas Indigent Defense Commission, said the lopsided funding contributes “to uneven defense across the state” and intensifies the money problems that counties face.
“While we’ve made progress, the law hasn’t reached its full promise because ([the state of) Texas doesn’t pay its fair share,” Ellis said in his statement. “Roughly 80% of criminal defendants can’t afford an attorney and require one to be appointed. So when public defense fails, criminal justice fundamentally fails.”

Democratic state Sen. Judith Zaffirini, whose district stretches from the U.S.-Mexico border to South Austin, has been trying to get the state to pay more. In 2025 she passed a bill to strengthen and better fund indigent defense. But Gov. Greg Abbott vetoed it, writing that it would have allowed “convicted criminals” to wrongly exploit the habeas corpus process.
In a statement to the Austin Free Press, Zaffirini wrote that she is working with Abbott’s staff “to address his objections” while consulting with other stakeholders to develop proposals for the 2027 legislative session.
“Additional state funding could help counties recruit and retain qualified attorneys” for indigent defense,” Zaffirini wrote, reducing disparities between urban and rural communities.
In its appropriations request, TIDC called the attorney shortage a “crisis” that is growing worse across Texas. Nearly one in three Texas attorneys handling indigent defense cases is “overburdened,” according to the TIDC.
“The attorney shortage crisis is something we’re really focused on in rural areas, but there are more and more counties, urban counties, that are showing shortages as well,” TIDC’s Ehlers said.
Travis County
Two entities are charged with representing indigent defendants in Travis County.
The county-funded Capital Area Private Defender Service (CAPDS), is a nonprofit assigned-counsel program created in 2014 by the Austin Criminal Defense Lawyers Association, the Austin Bar Association and the Travis County Criminal Judiciary.

Another is the Travis County Public Defender’s Office, which opened in 2020. It’s headed by Adeola Ogunkeyede, a former University of Virginia law professor who also worked on indigent defense for the New York nonprofit Bronx Defenders.
The Public Defender’s Office handles about a quarter of Travis County indigent cases and CAPDS handles the rest. Yet the number of CAPDS attorneys has shrunk over the past decade from roughly 250 to 125, said the group’s executive director, Bradley Hargis.

Ogunkeyede and Hargis say that a shrinking pool of qualified attorneys face mounting caseloads, increasing felony offenses and a surging jail population.
Criminal defense is a “tough profession” that requires committed attorneys who “believe in justice and … want to help people,” Ogunkeyede said. “We’re coming into it with the sentiment and the desire to be the best lawyers we can be.” Yet those attorneys face “a caseload crisis,” as “they are overloaded with cases and clients.”
The public defender’s office currently has some 60 attorneys in addition to investigators, social workers, legal secretaries and other positions. Its fiscal 2027 funding request seeks six more lawyers.
CAPDS assigns cases to about 125 “panel attorneys” backed by a staff of about 30 social workers, case managers, and other personnel.
“You can’t have the number of cases that we have with the resources we have and continue to get the outcomes we expect and that our clients deserve,” Hargis said. “Something has to give.”
“The bottom line is, it threatens our fundamental bedrock of democracy — the right to an attorney and a right to a trial,” Hargis said. “Justice delayed is justice denied.”
David Montgomery’s five-decade career with the Dallas Times Herald, Fort Worth Star-Telegram and Knight Ridder covered Texas, Washington, D.C., and Russia. Montgomery grew up in Abilene and is a graduate of the University of Missouri School of Journalism.

