| Getting your Trinity Audio player ready... |
District 10 Council Member Marc Duchen was the sole dissenter in the Austin City Council’s 10-1 vote to approve an unprecedented $6.3 billion budget on August 14. Afterwards, Duchen discussed the city budget and taxes with Austin Free Press. The interview has been edited for brevity and clarity.
What do you make of a city council that frequently discusses Austin’s affordability challenges seeking a property-tax increase?
If I take off my city council hat, I’d be puzzled and frustrated by that disconnect. Because everybody acknowledges we’ve got critical affordability problems and we should be as mindful as possible of that in making all our decisions.
Why did you vote against the city’s $6.3 billion budget for the coming fiscal year?
I’ve heard a lot of concerns about the cost of living increasing at a pace that exceeds people’s means. We’ve got a lot of folks living on the cusp of being pushed out of the city. We also hear from community groups worried about how different budget cuts impact vulnerable residents. My belief was that raising taxes will make this city less affordable for everybody, including the folks who are trying to find the dollars for the most vulnerable residents.

Affordability is the top of the list. We’re increasing the city’s wealth divide that separates who can afford to stay here and who can’t. Last year, taxes and fees went up for the average person about $1,200. This year it might be another $1,000. The county already has indicated it plans to do an 8 percent tax increase. How do we make sure that people can afford to stay here? Though my colleagues are generous about funding programs for vulnerable people, we’re asking the very next most vulnerable person to fund all that. That’s who it impacts most disproportionately.

This is a Band-Aid budget on top of a structural deficit. We’re spending more than we’re taking in. We could be back here in one or two years if things go sideways even just a little bit: less construction, higher inflation, whatever. A major reason why I didn’t vote for the budget is that I did not feel like we did everything that we could have done to find cost savings and efficiencies.

Do your colleagues give you flack about not being a team player?
I have not gotten much flack from them. Maybe there’s an understanding that my outlook and constituency is different from theirs? Well, I’m not going to speculate. But, no, nobody’s been giving me any flack for my vote or for my take on spending.
Has the city done polling on the tax increase?
The city did some surveying. I think it found that 14 percent of respondents wanted more spending and therefore more taxes. Everybody else wanted the same tax levels or less. We also did some surveying in my district, getting more than 260 responses. In our district about 5 percent wanted more spending and everybody else wanted the same or less. Or they answered the question in a different way, saying that the city spends the right amount of money but not on the priorities that I want.

We also received more than 600 constituent emails saying, “We don’t want a tax rate increase beyond the 3.5 percent hike” (that the city can make without calling an election).
Will voters approve the tax increase?
If you look at certain pockets online, people are pretty hostile to this tax rate election. Meanwhile, some council speakers offered to knock on as many doors as needed to get it passed. In my district, there’s not a great appetite for it.
Another part is who comes out to support and oppose it? If people dump $1 million into evangelizing on homelessness and other spending, that’s one thing. If people say, ‘Hang on, this is a permanent tax increase that pays for things that we’re not even sure are working,’ then that’s different. This is an opportunity for people to check the city council in a broad stroke. People might use that opportunity to say, ‘Guys, you need to do better.’ Generally speaking, I would agree with them.
If voters approve the tax increase in November does it just apply to the fiscal 2025-26 budget — or is it ongoing?
It’s a permanent tax increase.
What do you think of the recent legal challenge alleging that the city’s ballot language for the tax increase is misleading?
“I support the plaintiff’s right to bring this case. If its claims are valid, then I have faith the court will take appropriate action.”
While balancing revenue and spending is tough, do you see opportunities for big-ticket savings?
Obviously, there’s the capital improvement projects that I think could be absolutely scrutinized. And Project Connect and the convention center are programs where we need robust and public conversations around whether decisions made years ago to approve those dollars are still as worthwhile as they might have looked then.
I’m hoping to get a commitment from the city manager and, eventually, my colleagues to do the kind of performance audit that Houston has undertaken under Mayor John Whitmire. A combination of city staff and consultants had a 10-week engagement with the Ernst and Young accounting firm. They’re now starting to implement those recommendations and, apparently, already have found about $122 million in savings and efficiencies.
One of my chief complaints is that our council doesn’t have great ways to evaluate how we’re doing. It’s really hard for me to double down to trim a program that’s not performing. We don’t have that ability, even though you’re talking about literally billions of dollars of spending.
My team spent six weeks trying to gather data on contracts and vacancies and all of the ways that you would try and figure out how to be smart about spending. In the end, we realized we were kind of doing the staff’s job. New City Manager T.C. Broadnax hasn’t had enough time to implement all this. He’s really having to turn a battleship to get to a better place.
Anything else to add?

I put a lot of data on the city council message board about the state of the city. We’ve got a school district that’s hemorrhaging students. The overall metropolitan region is still doing well but just like 7 percent of the people moving here are actually moving into Austin city limits.

However well-intentioned it might be to try to help people, if you don’t have a broad tax base you wind up in a death spiral where people leave, it gets harder to find dollars, and you have to spend more money on ever increasing amounts of social services because you keep leaving people behind.
That’s one reason why a lot of the business community come out to oppose the tax rate. They’re in the same place of uncertainty. By some accounts, the average household will pay about $2,400 more a year due to tariffs. If inflation gets worse, that’s more pressure on voters. I think we should be really mindful of those things, trust the voters to make the right choice in November, and then hopefully, by then, have made progress on an audit and finding savings and efficiencies. It’s easier to spend money than to get good data, to say ‘No’ to people, to sharpen pencils and find savings and efficiencies. But Houston’s managed to do it without having to pay an enormous price.
Council Member Duchen said that City of Austin surveys found that just “14 percent of respondents wanted more spending and therefore more taxes.” Austin Free Press formally asked for copies of “polling, surveying, canvassing, or focus-group research” that the city conducted on possible tax rate elections in 2025 or 2026.
The city responded on Aug. 22 that it “has no responsive documents.”
