Musk-eteers: Tesla and Travis County conceal key Gigafactory tax-break records

Author Avatar
Tesla’s 7.9 million square-foot Gigafactory east of Austin
Tesla’s 7.9 million square-foot Gigafactory east of Austin. Image Credit: Tesla.
Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

Reporter’s Notebook:

It was supposed to be a simple, quick story.

Back in May, Austin Free Press assigned me to write a Tesla article. It aimed to focus on whether the world’s most-successful electric-vehicle company has lived up to promises it made in exchange for lucrative tax breaks and incentives to build its 10-million square-foot “Gigafactory” in Del Valle.

The story also would look at the company’s community impact in east Travis County, including the economic benefits, such as new jobs, contributions to Del Valle school district, and moving Tesla’s global headquarters to Austin. The story also would examine potential costs, such as environmental concerns, water usage, worker injuries, and tax revenues that the deal traded away. At the time, Tesla had just announced it was laying off 10 percent of its workforce but still appeared to be far exceeding its commitment to hire 5,000 Gigafactory workers, even after those layoffs.

That’s ambitious reporting — but not impossible.

The story requires talking to government executives, such as Travis County’s Planning and Budget Office, researching disclosures that Tesla has filed with the Securities and Exchange Commission and reported to shareholders, and, crucially, allowing Tesla to respond to questions that this research might raise.

Four months later, Tesla has not responded to multiple emails and calls for even basic information about the Gigafactory. That is not unusual for the high-profile company that famously did away with its PR department in 2020. What was surprising was Travis County’s response. Travis County Judge Andy Brown and multiple Travis County commissioners, initially told Austin Free Press that they were interested in talking, only to then fail to respond to follow-up calls seeking interviews.

Most disturbingly, the formal request for public records that I filed with Travis County in early June has dragged out for months. Assistant County Attorney Matthew Entsminger responded to my initial request under the Texas Public Open Records Act by saying the county would charge $360 to compile the requested information. That isn’t much for the New York Times but it’s not a negligible amount for a nonprofit news startup. Nonetheless, Austin Free Press paid the $360.

By contrast, Del Valle Independent School District promptly fulfilled a similar information request at no charge. The documents that Del Valle provided include copies of multi-million-dollar checks that it received from Tesla and details on other contributions that Tesla made to the district to comply with its economic incentive agreement.

Travis County has been far more secretive. In a surprise letter on July 31, Entsminger asked the Texas Attorney General to rule that the county did not need to make public all the requested information, citing wide-ranging exceptions to the Public Information Act (sections 552.101 through 552.158). The attorney general is expected to respond by October 2.

Taxpayer “trade secrets”

Tesla, meanwhile, filed a third-party response, objecting to the release of “correspondence that includes written formal communication as well as emails” related to the Gigafactory’s incentives deal from the original request.

Tesla said in its response that some information should be exempted because it contains email and phone information for Tesla employees, but also that some of it is “confidential trade secrets or commercial information.”

“Tesla guards its confidential business information as extremely proprietary and has stringent protocols that such information is protected,” wrote Brian Leahy, associate general counsel for Tesla.

That conflict about what is or isn’t protected under state law brings into focus the rocky political and legal terrain between private companies’ right to keep secret details regarding tax breaks and incentives when they do business with governmental bodies and the public’s right to know how incentives and tax breaks generated with their dollars benefit private companies.

Travis County finally did release some (but not all!) of the information requested in August.

Two chunky PDF files included Tesla’s original applications for the project under the name “Colorado River Project, LLC,” compliance reports from 2020 to 2024,  OSHA-reported injuries and a “Community Investment Update” detailing the Gigafactory’s community partnerships, utilization of HUBs (Historically Underutilized Businesses), and an estimate of the economic impacts of Tesla’s $10 billion investment and more than 12,000 employees. The information sent did include email addresses and phone numbers for some Tesla employees, including legal counsel and members of the company’s human-resources team. It also included an entire brochure detailing Tesla’s employee health-benefits package.

This is a start. But we still don’t know what we don’t know. Travis County has not released any correspondence with Tesla or its subsidiaries that might reveal how the terms of the Gigafactory deal were negotiated and any problems or concerns that have arisen since Tesla broke ground on the Gigafactory’s construction.

Bill Aleshire, a public-records expert and former Travis County Judge, expressed disappointment in Travis County’s handling of the request, including the money it charged to assemble the information. “That’s ridiculous,” he said. “There’s no way it took somebody that long to pull those records.”

Richest man’s documents

Tesla is a special case. It’s the region’s highest-profile company run by the world’s richest man. Tesla CEO Elon Musk makes headlines simply by posting on social media. But in recent weeks, we’ve been reminded of why a watchdog role is critical. The Wall Street Journal exposed how Tesla CEO Elon Musk covertly spent hundreds of thousands of dollars on nasty political ads attacking Travis County Attorney José Garza earlier this year. Meanwhile, local police records call into question Musk’s claims that he’s been the target of armed assassination attempts at the Gigafactory.

Tesla CEO Elon Musk.
Tesla CEO Elon Musk. Image credit: Justin Pacheco.

Given their outsized impact on the economics and culture of our region (along with Musk’s two other newly Texas-based companies, SpaceX and X), it’s important to track what Musk and his companies are doing — and how it impacts Central Texas. That means digging through public records and reporting what’s relevant to the public’s interest.

It’s not such a simple story anymore, but we’re determined to tell it.

We hope that Attorney General Ken Paxton denies the attempts by Tesla and Travis County to withhold records related to Tesla’s local tax breaks. As Aleshire says, “The information doesn’t belong to them. It belongs to the people.”

Omar L. Gallaga has covered technology and tech culture for Wired, CNET, NPR, Texas Monthly, The Wall Street Journal, CNN and the Austin American-Statesman, where he wrote about Austin’s tech scene since before the dot-com boom. You can hear him discuss tech every week on the Texas Standard radio show.

Disclosure: Bill Aleshire is an Austin Free Press donor.

Support independent journalism. Your tax-deductible donation helps keep independent journalism free. 

Read More

Scroll to Top