| Getting your Trinity Audio player ready... |
To reach the next stage of its clean-energy future, Austin Energy’s GreenChoice program must move beyond its focus on clean but intermittent wind and solar energy. Instead, it’s time to invest in energy storage and on-demand “dispatchable” renewable energies that supply power when the wind and sun do not.
The most-promising technologies to deliver these benefits are geothermal power plants combined with large batteries to store electricity to provide clean energy all day and all night. These and similar innovations will be essential for Austin to successfully treat its addiction to fossil and nuclear fuels.
Austin’s award-winning GreenChoice program started buying wind power in 2001. Mirroring the state as a whole, Austin Energy’s share of renewables-based electricity grew from almost nothing to 51 percent in 2023. With strong local renewables support and falling renewables costs, Austin is projected to hit 80 percent renewables by 2035.

That target cannot be achieved, however, with intermittent wind and solar alone. That’s why Austin’s once-innovative GreenChoice program has become obsolete. The good news is that Austin can repurpose GreenChoice to invest in energy storage and dispatchable green energies, which crank out electricity on demand.
In 2022, about 28,000 Austin Energy customers subscribed to GreenChoice (6 percent of the total). For that privilege, the average GreenChoice residential subscriber paid a 6 percent premium on her Austin Energy bill. Residential and commercial GreenChoice revenues brought in an extra $7.4 million that year.
GreenChoice can expand that revenue stream by leveraging that money with private investor funds. Combining that money with grants from governments, non-profits, and other utility companies, it can invest in the dispatchable green energy and energy storage technologies that can take Austin to the next level of clean energy.
One of the oldest and most established dispatchable renewable technologies is hydroelectric power. While the Lower Colorado River Authority operates hydroelectric dams along the Highland Lakes above Austin, suitable geology restricts hydroelectric options in Texas. A more promising local option is enhanced geothermal energy. The Texas oil industry’s drilling experience can be repurposed to tap thermal energy deep underground to produce renewable power on demand.
Geothermal energy has long been used in areas where the earth’s heat naturally rises to the surface via volcanoes, hot springs, or geysers. Elsewhere, drilling down one to three miles often hits temperatures of 500 degrees Fahrenheit, dramatically expanding geothermal’s range. Ironically, the Texas oil industry’s drilling expertise can help enable this kind of dispatchable renewable power. Modern horizontal drilling techniques that enabled fracking have the potential to reduce geothermal drilling costs by 90 percent.
GreenChoice should also invest in battery storage capacity. Batteries store wind and solar energy when its plentiful and cheap for use when it is scarce and expensive. This smooths out the ebbs and flows of intermittent renewables. Lithium batteries are today’s workhorses for both electric vehicles and electric utilities. But researchers are tinkering with sodium, flow, and thermal batteries to potentially replace lithium in the near future.

Geothermal power and battery storage may be currently more expensive than lithium battery storage. But they have the potential to be less expensive over the long term, much as wind and solar power costs plummeted as investment soared.
An updated GreenChoice program could continue to rely on some Austin Energy customers willing to pay a premium for the greater good. However, some of the future GreenChoice investments in the revised program might even make money.
With new battery technology, Austin Energy could turn a profit by buying power during summer-time nights at 1.5¢ per kilowatt and reselling it the next afternoon – when air conditioners are cranking – for 33 times more (50 cents/KW). Through such arbitrage, Austin Energy could lower your power bills or pocket a profit, even as it creates greater economies of scale for these technologies – lowering their costs.
The existing GreenChoice program enjoys brand loyalty. To ensure a successful transition, Austin Energy should poll existing subscribers, the general public, and industry experts, to gauge acceptance for the new direction, as well as new reasons that would motivate more participation.
Municipal utilities often avoid subjecting ratepayers to financial risks. But ratepayers face other risks as carbon-driven climate change continues to hammer the planet. While this GreenChoice investment strategy isn’t guaranteed to break even, it will deliver assets that save, store, or produce green energy, lowering green technology costs.
Some of these new technologies can be manufactured, installed and operated in Central Texas, creating local investment and jobs, perhaps even turning Austin into a clean-energy manufacturing hub.
Continuing to rely on the existing, obsolete GreenChoice program will not lead Austin into a completely renewable energy future. Pivoting to energy storage and dispatchable renewables and energy storage such as geothermal power and new battery technologies could do just that.
Sodium batteries
Scientists are researching better alternatives to the lithium batteries used by most electric utilities and electric vehicles today. Sodium batteries are a promising option, with some protypes already approaching the weight efficiency of lithium batteries. Sodium batteries operate well in very cold weather, whereas the range of lithium-battery vehicles can plummet 41 percent in cold weather.
In 2024, there were about 25 companies working on sodium batteries, with at least eight manufacturing them. China’s HiNa Battery is building the largest sodium battery project in the world: a 100 megawatt facility for a data center. U.S.-based Natron Energy has commissioned a Michigan plant to produce 600 megawatts annually for data centers, critical power, forklifts, and EV fast-charging.
Closed-loop geothermal Energy
Unlike solar and wind power, geothermal technology offers renewable energy on demand. Canada-based Eavor Technologies harvests geothermal heat by pumping a cold fluid down into a whisker-shaped “radiator” drilled into hot, underground rock. The heated fluid drawn up a second well can then be used to generate electricity, as well as for industrial or residential heating. Germany began the first commercial installation of this technology in 2023. Upon completion next year it will go 14,800 feet underground to tap 8.2 megawatts of electricity and 64 megawatts of heat.
A system tested by California’s GreenFire Energy inserts a cold and a hot tube into a single well, pumping cold fluid down one, while extracting heated fluid through the other. GreenFire is developing a commercial facility at the world’s largest geothermal plant: the Geysers north of San Francisco.
This opinion piece is adapted from Paul Robbins’ new article, “Gambling for the Planet: Austin’s Clean-Energy Backup Plan.” Robbins is an environmental activist and consumer advocate. He is the editor of the Austin Environmental Directory, a sourcebook of environmental issues, organizations, products, and services.

