| Getting your Trinity Audio player ready... |
Thursday the Austin City Council is scheduled to consider saving animal shelter money by revising city reporting of the spaying of visibly pregnant animals and by adjusting how it calculates live-release rates (agenda item 3). What could be wrong with that?
Maybe plenty!
In 2010 the council approved a “no-kill plan” to stop the city from killing animals “for their own good” without a sound medical reason or because the city lacks such resources as space. Later the city adopted a 95 percent live shelter-release rate.
If the city changes how it records euthanasia and other lethal procedures, the shelter could kill more animals while still claiming a 95 percent live-release rate. At what point might such accounting tricks abandon “no kill” altogether? Without transparency, it will be impossible for the average citizen to know what’s going on.
Driving these proposed changes is the fact that the Austin Animal Center is far too often full, closing its doors to new-animal intakes. If you can’t just kill them, then you must find them homes — the very heart of no-kill policy. Currently, such placements aren’t happening fast enough.

The math is simple. The number of animals moving out of the shelter must slightly exceed the number of animals that it takes in. Since the animal center is not accomplishing that, it closes intakes, prompting citizens to complain about the animal shelter.
No kill is what most Austinites appear to want and it has worked well in past years. Nonetheless, there still are Austinites who believe that no kill is impossible. This camp frequently denounces no kill as “slow kill,” which is inaccurate since animals would be killed at faster rates without the no kill policy. These people assume without presenting any evidence that the number of animals in Austin far exceeds potential homes for them. If this is true, then the shelter will always be full and the only choice is to “do away” with the excess animals.
Given no kill’s popularity, however, it’s more politically expedient to change how the “kill” rate is counted, and “do away” with transparency about how many animals actually are killed. That way, perhaps nobody will notice.
A different approach assumes that no kill can succeed with the right leadership. The shelter director must believe in no kill — and that there are plenty of homes in Austin to house all the animals (data support this contention). The director’s job is to form good relationships with partner organizations, volunteers, and the public. Bring everyone on board to make it a community effort. Educate. Invite people into the shelter. Put operating procedures in place to guarantee transparency and ensure that all citizens and their pets are treated equally, fairly and humanely.
Which approach is correct? A basic truth that I learned years ago is that thoughts are creative. Humans are powerful creatures. What we think in our heads creates a reality in the world around us. No kill only works if the director believes that it can and does what’s necessary to make it work. Those positive thoughts and actions can make no kill a living reality in Austin. Such directors exist. No kill can succeed in Austin with a shelter director who believes in it enough to make it happen.

The Austin Animal Center now is administered by Acting Director Rolando Fernandez, who came from the Austin Convention Center with little shelter experience in April. Does he believe in no kill enough to make it work? I don’t know. If so, why is he seeking these changes?
Here’s a suggestion. Rather than reducing transparency through administrative changes that hide increasing kill rates, why not find a shelter director who believes in no kill enough to make it work?
Craig Nazor is the Conservation Chair of the Sierra Club’s Lone Star Chapter in Austin. He served on the Austin Animal Advisory Commission for eight years.

