| Getting your Trinity Audio player ready... |
Editor’s note: Today at 9 a.m. the Travis County Commissioners Court will discuss a new performance review of Central Health, the tax-funded hospital district overseeing indigent health care. A leading critic of Central Health wrote this opinion piece. Austin Free Press has invited Central Health to submit a response.
Local advocates have been asking a simple question since 2016: How much has the University of Texas Dell Medical School spent on health care for the poor in exchange for the $385 million — and counting — it has received from Central Health?
Despite opposition from Central Health, UT-Austin, and some local public officials, Travis County commissioners finally hired the international consulting firm Mazars to conduct an independent performance audit in April 2023. The main purpose of that $854,200 audit was to verify how much health care the medical school has provided to the poor for the $35 million a year that it receives from Central Health, the hospital district for Travis County.
Pact with the poor
The Texas Constitution authorizes special-purpose hospital districts, such as Central Health, to provide health care to a county’s poor residents. Hospital districts provide a crucial safety net in Texas, which leads the nation with more than 5 million uninsured residents. About 160,000 of those live in Travis County.
I voted with the Travis County majority to establish a local hospital district in 2004. I voted with the majority again to approve a 2012 Central Health tax increase “for improved health care in Travis County, including support for a new medical school consistent with the mission of Central Health” among other items. The Austin-American Statesman reported at the time that the tax increase “would increase Central Health’s annual revenue by $54 million, with $35 million of that permanently earmarked for services provided to needy patients by the proposed medical school’s faculty, students and residents.” That turned out to be false.
At a lawyer friend’s request, I volunteered to look at Central Health and the medical school in 2016. Eventually, I made a public information act request to Central Health and Dell Medical asking how much health care the medical school had dispensed for the $105 million that it then had received from Central Health. I knew something was terribly wrong when they both responded that they had no such documentation.

With experience in health insurance law and financial fraud investigations, I knew that all medical care has to be documented. I requested details on every medical school employee funded by Central Health’s annual $35 annual million payments. Bingo. Those UT records, as I documented in a 2017 report, showed that Central Health’s funds overwhelmingly paid for medical school personnel engaged in the medical school’s general operations — not for medical care.
The Austin NAACP, LULAC, and other advocates asked county commissioners for an independent audit, prompting behind-the-scenes resistance from Central Health, UT, and Travis County staff, including the County Attorney’s Office (which receives around $400,000 to represent Central Health in governance matters).
Commissioners ordered a 2017 review conducted under Central Health’s control. It failed to address the key issue: How much health care is the medical school providing to the poor? Instead, it confirmed that the medical school spent its Central Health funds on operational expenses (which was never in doubt).
Show us the money
Grassroots leaders and I met with Dell Medical School officials that year, telling them that we would not sue them if they agreed to keep records going forward to prove that they were spending the $35 million a year in taxpayer dollars on health care for the poor. Unable to secure a commitment, we sued Central Health that year on behalf of local property taxpayers. That pending lawsuit seeks to stop the hospital district from spending taxpayer dollars on nonmedical-care activities in the future.
I accidentally discovered in 2021 that UT requires the medical school to classify every expenditure by standardized budget codes. Those subpoenaed records eventually showed that the medical school officially classified 90 percent of its Central Health-funded expenditures as going to education, research, and other non-clinical operations. Meanwhile, just 10 percent of the money went to clinical operations that might provide health care to the poor. Even for those clinical expenditures, the medical school had no records showing that this medical care treated poor patients, as legally required. The records do not document one penny of Central Health’s $385 million dollars providing medical care to the poor. After LULAC and NAACP reported these findings, the Commissioners Court finally ordered an audit in July 2022.
Two years in the making, that Mazars’s performance audit just landed. Remarkably, its 157-page report again dodges the central question: How much, if any, of the $385 million paid to the Dell Medical School funded the treatment of poor patients. In my opinion, the Commissioners Court should refuse to pay Mazars for that part of the report that was supposed to address this $385 million question.
The Mazars report ignores indisputable facts about how the medical school spent $35 million in annual Central Health payments, as uncovered through litigation and Texas Public Information Act requests. These facts include that the medical school:
- Spent just 10 percent of the $35 million in annual payments on expenditures officially classified as clinical or clinical administration.
- Produced no records demonstrating that any of those clinical expenditures provided medical care to low-income residents.
- Spent hundreds of millions of dollars on medical school salaries, student admissions, research, fundraising, public relations, and other expenses that have nothing to do with treating the poor.
- Does not provide medical care to poor patients. A medical school affiliated physicians’ practice group, UT Health Austin, provides those clinical functions, which are financed by Central Health funds other than the $35 million annual payments going to Dell Medical School.
It’s worth noting that the UT System classifies the $35 million annual payment as a gift for which nothing is owed in return.
Let’s keep in mind that about 91,000 low-income Travis County residents eligible for Central Health coverage are not being covered.
The Affiliation Agreement governing the $35 annual million payments purports to grant UT “discretion” to spend those funds essentially on any operations or administrative costs the medical school wishes. But that Affiliation Agreement is trumped by the state law that mandates that Central Health’s funds be spent on health care for poor county residents.
Remarkably, the Affiliation Agreement lacks standard provisions that would allow Central Health to control and monitor the medical school’s use of taxpayer dollars. The agreement has no scope of services, no payment methodology, no medical recordkeeping nor reporting requirements, no right to reimbursement for improper payments, and no right to inspect or audit.
By contrast, Central Health did include these protective provisions in its health services agreements with UT Health Austin and Ascension Seton. The Affiliation Agreement basically makes the hospital district a permanent, major funding source for a medical school that the Texas Legislature refused to bankroll.
Independent performance audits are essential to ensure that government funds are spent legally and efficiently. Why cannot Central Health, UT, Travis County, and local leaders admit the truth about the medical school’s expenditures? Perhaps the ugly truth is illegal and contradicts Travis County’s purported liberalism.
Fred Lewis has been a public interest lawyer and advocate for 40 years. He graduated from UT Law School with high honors. He is an independent liberal who believes in the rule of law and not taking health-care dollars from the poor. He is serving pro bono on the Central Health litigation.
Disclosure: Fred Lewis is an Austin Free Press donor.

