| Getting your Trinity Audio player ready... |
Update: Democratic Hays County Judge Ruben Becerra, the commissioner’s court’s presiding officer, sent Austin Free Press this statement after publication:
“I am not inclined to appeal and spend another hundred thousand dollars only to find us at the exact same point we are now,” Becerra wrote. “However, I will reserve judgement until we receive all of the facts. While I respect the ruling issued I’m very disappointed in the lack of transparency and public input we had on this bond issue. Unfortunately, every chance I had to bring up transparency and input was shut down by the special interests on our court.”
In a rare, if not unprecedented move, a Travis County district judge this week blocked $440 million in road bonds that Hays County voters approved last fall, finding that the county violated the Texas Open Meetings Act.
Judges generally are reluctant to undo voter decisions, said Austin attorney Bill Aleshire, who represented the plaintiffs. Other lawyers agree.

“I’ve seen and read all the cases on this,” said Houston Attorney Joe Larsen, an Open Meetings Act expert on the board of the Freedom of Information Foundation of Texas. “I’ve never heard of a bond issue that’s been reversed” based on open-meetings violations. “It took courage for the court to do.”

Hays County commissioners in one of Texas’ fastest growing counties unanimously voted in August 2024 to present local voters with a $440 million bond proposition for a package of 31 road projects, including some over the Edwards Aquifer. Two weeks before that November election, four property owners filed a lawsuit alleging that the commissioners broke the open-meetings law. That legal action was later combined with a bond-validation lawsuit that Hays County filed with State District Judge Catherine Mauzy, who presides over the 419th Civil District Court in Austin.
The plaintiffs claimed that the Hays County Commission publicly posted the bond election agenda without stating the bond’s purpose, its dollar value, or the amount of the proposed tax increase that Hays County residents would incur. The county listed the bond in the agenda’s “Miscellaneous” section instead of in the “Roads” section, where a much smaller road bond package was posted — along with its dollar value.
Texas courts have ruled that notices of government meetings require greater specificity where matters of special public interest are concerned. The plaintiffs argued that a $440 million tax increase for road bonds met that test.
Lawyers for the county commissioners countered in court filings that no open-meeting violation occurred and that “29 citizens provided public comment” on the bond proposal. They also denounced the lawsuit as an “attempt to circumvent the political process.”

Last November, 56 percent of Hays County voters approved the bonds. In her recent pretrial judgment, however, Mauzy ruled that the county’s posted agenda on the bond proposal “violates the Texas Open Meetings Act public notice requirement.” Her ruling declared the resulting “election void.”

A Hays County commissioner posted on Facebook that he was, “Disappointed beyond belief” with Mauzy’s ruling. “A TRAVIS County District judge chose to ignore over 100 thousand of our citizens,” Precinct 4 Commissioner Walt Smith, a Republican, wrote. “Let us make our own decisions in Hays County about what’s right and wrong.”
Hays County Judge Ruben Becerra, a county spokesperson, and a defense lawyer in the case, Michael Shaunessy, did not immediately respond to questions about if the county intends to appeal Judge Mauzy’s ruling.
A plaintiff in the case hails from Smith’s district along the central part of the Hays-Travis County border. “We held numerous meetings with him” but Smith “was not in concert with our environmental concerns,” Catherine Ramsey told Austin Free Press. “Whether Democratic or Republican, we recognize that we’re sitting over the contributing zone of the aquifer and that whether or not we construct dense construction out here has serious implications further downstream.”
For landowners along Onion Creek where the RM 150 extension was planned, Ramsey said that “the biggest issue is that the road would require an eminent-domain taking of their land.”
Aleshire said he originally filed the lawsuit in Hays County. The case got transferred, he said, as a result of Hays County filing a related bond-validation lawsuit in Travis County.
Part of the Hays County bond package was to connect State Highway 45 to I-35. This caused friction between Hays County and Travis County Commissioners, who opposed extending that trans-county road.
Hays County commissioners “need to take a step back and be more open and inclusive about road planning and doubling the County’s outstanding indebtedness,” Aleshire said in a statement.

Image credit: Andrew Wheat.
Aleshire won a similar victory last year on behalf of the environmental nonprofit Save Our Springs Alliance (whose attorneys Bill Bunch and Bobby Levinski also represented the Hays County case plaintiffs).
That lawsuit alleged that the Austin City Council violated the same provisions of the state open-meetings law when it voted to place city charter amendments on the November 2024 ballot. Ruling last August, Travis County District Court Judge Maya Guerra Gamble barred the city of Austin from pursuing that charter election. “The public interest is best served by enforcing the Texas Open Meetings Act,” she ruled, “even if the City’s election would be delayed.”
Taken together, Aleshire said, the two recent decisions show that “violating the Open Meetings Act is fatal.”
Andrew Wheat is the managing editor of the Austin Free Press.
Bill Bunch sits on the Austin Free Press Advisory Board.

