| Getting your Trinity Audio player ready... |
City of Austin officials have paused their request to demolish the historic Barton Springs Road Bridge, slowing a controversial project that has drawn outcry from preservationists, architects and environmentalists.
The city’s Capital Delivery Services department withdrew its demolition application just before the Historic Landmark Commission’s March 4 meeting. Commission members had planned to continue to review the proposal but city staff said that more work was required before the landmark commission could evaluate the project.

Credit: Richard Stone
“This application was premature as the project design hasn’t progressed enough to provide the information necessary for the review,” Capital Delivery Services Deputy Director Eric Bailey wrote the commission. “Staff will return to the (commission) as the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) process continues with input from federal agencies and public comment.”

Bailey asked to brief the landmark commission at its April 1 meeting. Commission officials said that it would be on the agenda for discussion only.
Commission Chair Ben Heimsath said he would “encourage everybody to participate every way you can, and I certainly will do my best to explore avenues with staff — if not in the April meeting but in future meetings — where we will be able to have the full amount of public participation that this item deserves regarding its historic significance,” he said.

Last month, Heimsath and other commissioners balked when they were asked to sign off on the demolition and replacement of the 100-year-old Barton Springs Road Bridge. Although the Austin City Council decided more than two years ago to demolish the bridge, which is one of six contributing structures included in the Zilker Park Historic District, it wasn’t until February that city landmark commissioners were asked to weigh in on the project.
“There is a level of expertise that we bring to the city,” architect and commission chair Ben Heimsath told city staff at the Feb. 4 meeting. “You have a city-owned property in a national registered historic district … And nobody asked, ‘Where is the, the (Austin Historic) Landmark Commission? Why are we not talking to them?’ I, I, I’m flabbergasted!”
At the March 4 meeting, Heimsath opened the public communications portion of the meeting to those who had signed up to speak about the bridge.

“The number of AIA members who have expressed interest and concern with proposed demolition in just the past couple of days has been really intense,” said the first speaker, Jason John Paul Haskins, the advocacy commissioner for the Austin chapter of the American Institute of Architects.
He said that while members’ concerns come from many different directions, all supported preserving the bridge.
“I thought this was a lost cause years ago,” Haskins said. “Now that the cost is escalating, hopefully we can work together to find a solution (and) work to encourage transparency reconsideration and preservation of this landmark.”
Charles Walker, a bridge engineer who formerly worked for the Texas Department of Transportation, told commissioners that he had worked on 43 historic bridges during his career. He said the report too quickly dismissed options for preserving the bridge’s structural arches.

Credit: Richard Stone
Walker suggested that a new floor system could be added to the bridge’s deck, preserving the supporting arches. The bridge floor system supports the bridge deck, distributing traffic loads to the bridge’s main supports. The city separately could add a parallel hike and bike bridge, Walker said.
“There are plenty of examples of bridges that have rebuilt the floor system and preserved the arches — Congress Avenue being one,” Walker said.

Credit: Richard Stone
Media have reported bridge replacement estimates ranging from $37 million to $54 million.

University of Texas-Austin architecture professor David Heymann expressed concerns about a new bridge’s carbon costs. He estimated that removing the existing bridge would have a carbon cost of up to 236 metric tons and building a new bridge could add an another 400 metric tons.
“If you repair the existing bridge and build a steel bridge (for pedestrians and cyclists) next to it, it would be about half the carbon cost of tearing the bridge out and replacing it with the new design,” he said.

Political pressure to reexamine the iconic bridge’s future increased during a site tour last month, when District 5 City Council Member Ryan Alter said he would suspend efforts to secure more money for a new bridge until he’s convinced that demolition is the only option.
Nonetheless, city officials told Austin Free Press in a Feb. 24 email that they are moving ahead with plans for a new bridge.

Credit: Richard Stone
“The City of Austin is proceeding with plans to replace the bridge,” said Transportation and Public Works Department spokesperson Jeff Stensland. “This is following Council direction in 2023.”
Richard Stone is a Central Texas native reporter and editor with 35 years of award-winning experience covering local issues that matter. More at Wilcoblues.com.

